Exploring the Gendered Empathy Gap Among White Evangelical Protestants

Bethany Mannon, Ph.D., is a 2026-2027 PRRI Public Fellow and an Associate Professor of English at Appalachian State University. She is the author of “I Grew Up in the Church”: How American Evangelical Women Tell Their Stories (Baylor University Press, 2024) and is currently writing a book about Rachel Held Evans (forthcoming from Baylor University Press in 2027).


Empathy has become a growing source of debate, with some conservative Americans questioning its role as a moral value. PRRI’s 2026 American Values Survey revealed an “empathy gap” dividing Republicans and white evangelicals from other Americans. This Spotlight Analysis examines how Americans’ views of empathy differ between men and women, and the possible implications for U.S. politics and religion.

While 68% of Americans and 84% of Democrats agree that empathy is a foundational moral value that helps build a healthy society, only 54% of Republicans surveyed hold that view. In contrast, 43% of Republicans — compared with 27% of all Americans — instead agree that empathy can “become dangerous when it leads people away from building a society guided by God’s truth.”

Views on empathy also divide white evangelical Protestants from other religious groups in the United States. They are the only religious group where a majority (54%) agree empathy can be dangerous. However, white evangelical men are more likely than white evangelical women to hold this view (59% vs. 51%). By contrast, white evangelical women are more likely than white evangelical men to say that “empathy is a foundational moral value that helps build a healthy society” (46% vs. 37%). Given the increasing liberal political identity of young women, vocal hostility to feminism among evangelicals, and a trend of women disaffiliating from organized religion, it is not surprising that the religious “empathy gap” may be related to gender.

This empathy gender gap also sets white evangelical Protestants apart from other religious groups. Only one other group captured in the survey shows an empathy gender gap for either question: Among white Catholics, significantly more men (36%) than women (27%) agree that empathy is dangerous. However, white Catholic men and women are similar in their positive views of empathy (63% and 68%, respectively).

When the 2026 American Values Survey came out, observers commented that this stance makes no sense for a religion defined by the Sermon on the Mount and the Golden Rule. In fact, as Robert P. Jones, PRRI’s president and founder, has argued, evangelical Protestants’ stance is the result of a “well-coordinated assault” by “theologians and influencers.” That movement has targeted women in particular. Pastor Joe Rigney, author of the 2025 book “The Sin of Empathy, leverages evangelical views of women as “the weaker vessel” — designed for parenting and homemaking, not public life — to delegitimize empathy. Allie Beth Stuckey’s podcast and her book “Toxic Empathy” address women and claim to show where the left is “distorting biblical love into progressive activism and manipulating women into supporting issues that are harmful and, in many cases, sinful.” Women are both the audience and the reason for this white evangelical war on empathy.

Why attack this concept that so many Americans, including so many Christians, consider a fundamental moral value? One reason might be that white evangelical leaders and influencers see empathy as a factor in the increasing liberal politics of young women. Empathy for the victims of sex abuse groups and for people marginalized by the church has also contributed to women leaving organized religion.

The war on empathy also advances a goal of limiting women’s participation in politics. For example, Pastor Dale Partridge argues for repealing women’s right to vote because of their empathy. In November 2025, he posted on X, “I don’t think we should repeal the 19th Amendment because I don’t love women. I think we should repeal the 19th Amendment because I love America and American women and want to protect our nation from their suicidal empathy.” Partridge was alleging that empathy was the reason young women overwhelmingly supported New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill, and Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger in the 2025 elections.

Opposition to women voting remains a fringe opinion. PRRI finds that only 8% of all Americans and 7% of both white evangelical men and women agree with repealing the 19th Amendment. However, the survey also shows that while 54% of white evangelical Protestants agree that “society is better off when men and women stick to the jobs and tasks they are naturally suited for,” white evangelical men are 10 percentage points more likely than white evangelical women to agree (59% vs. 49%). Complementarianism — the view that God created men and women to have distinct roles where men lead and women follow — is prevalent among white evangelical Protestants, as political scientists Paul A. Djupe and Brooklyn Walker have found. In an environment of growing skepticism toward empathy and considerable support for complementarianism, arguments against women’s political participation could find increasingly receptive audiences.

While the message that empathy is toxic or sinful only recently broke into mainstream political media, this war on empathy did not begin in the 2020s. In 2013, the influential writer and blogger Rachel Held Evans wrote “The Scandal of the Evangelical Heart.” Evans wrote that her doubts about Christianity and particularly the evangelical church came from “questions not of the mind but of the heart, questions of conscience and empathy.” She had been taught that her “intuitive sense of love and morality and right and wrong” was so corrupted by sin that she could not trust, for example, her horror at Old Testament stories of the slaughter of women and children. Evans rejects that, asking “Did following Jesus mean becoming some shadow of myself, drained of empathy and compassion and revulsion to injustice?” White evangelicals have attacked empathy for decades (maybe longer) as part of a long-term political and theological project.

Scroll to Top